However, the so-called “finder” or “starter” is an increasingly widespread phenomenon operating in a shadowy area: that is, private citizens who act as paid “whistleblowers” for properties about to be put up for sale on the market. The “tip-off,” but in this case in exchange for money from neighbors or “well-informed,” is a practice that real estate agencies increasingly use to intercept in advance houses for sale or potentially for sale. The practice of “tipping” – which can range from 50 to 500 euros, but also much more on expensive properties – to the whistleblower by agencies which, although seemingly harmless, leads to offenses such as illegal professional practice, the right to privacy, and tax violations.
”However, it is essential to remember – emphasizes lawyer Gennaro Sposato, real estate expert from the international multidisciplinary firm Rödl – that real estate brokerage activity is reserved for authorized individuals registered with the REA/Chamber of Commerce, the only ones entitled to the actual commission. Certainly, the simple passing of information by a private individual, such as a tip that the neighbor wants to sell houses, is lawful as an occasional informational activity – explains the expert -. However, if the whistleblower crosses this line and begins negotiating the price, organizing visits, or negotiating commissions, they perform acts typical of the real estate profession. In this case, the offense of unlawful exercise of mediation activity applies, as well as the loss of any right to compensation, ending with administrative monetary sanctions provided by law.”
A critical area is the one in which whistleblowers operate, not only from a contractual point of view but, as mentioned, also in terms of privacy and the processing of personal data. “Providing the name, contact number, or address of an owner without their knowledge constitutes a communication of personal data to third parties without a valid legal basis,” reminds Nadia Martini, Rödl lawyer, Italy’s leading expert in data protection, cybersecurity, and innovation. ”The whistleblower has no legal basis, nor the consent of the data subject, to communicate this data. The agency, moreover, that acquires the data and makes a commercial call to the owner without prior notice or consent and without respecting telemarketing codes of conduct, commits unlawful data processing and risks sanctions from the Privacy Authority. Furthermore, it is obliged to inform the data subject at the time of first contact or within a maximum of one month, specifying from which lawful source it obtained the data.”
IF THE “TIP” IS NOT – AS HAPPENS – DECLARED, TAX OFFENSE AND ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING ARE TRIGGERED
Last but not least, the so-called ‘tips’ given by real estate agencies to private citizens certainly raise tax questions.
For private individuals without a VAT number, in fact, these amounts must be declared among the other types of income and subject to withholding tax at the time of settlement by the agency. That is, the fee must be declared to the tax authorities and the real estate agency paying the amount must act as a withholding agent, applying and paying the 20% withholding tax and issuing the Single Certification. Furthermore, if a private individual systematically and continuously makes reports, the Revenue Agency can challenge the obligation to open a VAT number or the existence of an undeclared subordinate/collaboration relationship.
This thus constitutes violations for failure to invoice, failure to register with the social security system, and potential contestation of undeclared self-employment. It should also be kept in mind that payments for ‘tip-off’ generally made in cash or through untracked credit systems to evade taxes or hide the source violate the rules on traceability of financial flows and anti-money laundering regulations.














